You know what else I'm sick of people whingeing about? Communication technology. (Cell phones. The internet. You may have heard of them.)
First you've got your basic whingeing about how prevalent this technology is in our daily lives. I'm sure you've all heard these arguments: it infringes on our quiet time, it makes us ignore the people in our physical vicinity, yadda yadda yadda. Everybody forgets that these complaints can be traced not to the technology itself, but to how we use it--to our own nature and behavior. Technology doesn't
make us do a damned thing;
we make
it do stuff. And if we want a break from it, that's what the off switch is for. By now we should all recognize that communication technology it itself a GOOD THING. It makes our lives easier and safer. When I first got my driver's license and started driving alone, my parents REQUIRED me to have a cell phone because they wanted me to be able to call them and/or 911 if I had an accident. And then they asked me to turn it off during family supper.
But now we've got another incarnation of this anti-progress whingeing:
communication technology is TOO useful, and it's fucking with our fiction.
Conspiring with a distant lover? Try texting. Lost in the woods/wilderness/Ionic Sea? Use GPS. Case of mistaken identity? Facebook!
Technology is rendering obsolete some classic narrative plot devices: missed connections, miscommunications, the inability to reach someone. Such gimmicks don’t pass the smell test when even the most remote destinations have wireless coverage. (It’s Odysseus, can someone look up the way to Ithaca? Use the "no Sirens" route.)
[...]
Then I started talking to fellow writers and discovered a brewing antagonism toward today’s communication gadgets.
"We want a world where there’s distance between people; that’s where great storytelling comes from," [emphasis mine] said Kamran Pasha, a writer and producer on "Kings," the NBC drama based on the story of David.
The source of great storytelling is "distance between people"? Really? Because I thought the best source was human nature. Human life. Communication technology is
part of our lives now, and I don't see that it's taken away humanity's capacity for drama, or diminished life's capacity to throw us for a loop, no matter how much gadgetry we're toting around. In fact, there are plenty of times when
communication technology makes our lives and interactions MORE complicated and dramatic. The word "kerfluffle" comes directly from the internet, people!
And don't forget one of the most important aspects of technology, at least in terms of how we can use it in fiction: occasionally,
technology plays merry hell with us and/or punks out on us--sometimes at the moment we need it most. We break it, lose it, use up all its power. It craps out right after the warranty ends. It's vulnerable to viruses and "glitches" (my muscular buttocks) and spilled diet soda and the Patriot Act. Some of us don't know how to use it properly. Some of us are too poor to afford it and get left out of the loop while everyone around us is connected to each other. One day, it might acquire artificial intelligence.
Communication technology is an incredible gift AND a huge liability. Don't pout about it. Don't even write around it. Make it work within your stories. Honestly, has no one heard of sci-fi?